Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
12/28/11 06:00 PM
The Top Guitars: WTF?

Recently I stumbled across this website. In fact, the way I stumbled across it was by going a google search for Rickenbacker 4003 Firegloe, and in the midst of $1,900 and up price tags, low and behold there are some priced at $430 so curiosity got the best of me.

Anyway, check out the Rics, the Fenders, and the Gretsch’s this company is knocking off. They take patent and intellectual property infringement to a whole new level. They actually include the Rickenbacker, PRS, Fender, and Gretsch logos on the headstock…..WTF!....talk about unscrupulous business practices. Now, I’m all for replicating good products, adding your own twist to it, and selling it at a reduced price to undercut the competition, but this literally equates to intellectual rape, IMO.

I will give it to them, though, insomuch as the pics look convincing. Just at face value the Ric 4003 looks like a dead ringer. I couldn’t tell from the pics that it’s a knockoff. I read some online reviews from people brave enough and, I guess, unscrupulous enough to buy these, and they were generally positive. Change out the electronics, and they say you’ve got an instrument right on par with the real McCoy, but I just can’t get over the fact that they’re blatantly ripping off these other companies.

Chris


ickalien
(Planeteer)
12/28/11 06:17 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Wow, that is quite blatent isn't it.

I looked at the plexi-Stevie via Ibanez. I don't know just what to think about this.


slotz
(Planeteer)
12/28/11 06:31 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Wow. I guess if you put "type" or "style" after the name it's OK.

Marty Gilman
(Loquacious Planeteer)
12/28/11 06:55 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Asian knock-offs. There are lots of them out there, some decent.


-m


glensimonds
(Planeteer)
12/28/11 07:16 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

these say american made ? oops yea even those say made in bejing

Webster
(Planeteer)
12/28/11 08:45 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

"Honesty and intergrity"


Hmmmm.... ...ok.


flatcatAdministrator
(Loquacious Planeteer)
12/29/11 12:56 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

There was a big article I recently read about this. There are Martin guitars out there now that have the C.F. Martin name, logos, the whole thing on it. They are made in China. And there is nothing that the real C.F. Martin Co. in Nazareth PA can do about it.

There is no such thing as patent law protection in China. There is absolutely nothing preventing Chinese manufacturers from stealing not only designs, but brand identities from reputable companies.

It appears this is one of them.

How brazen, the Gretsch White Falcon says "Made in the U.S.A." stamped in gold on the back of the headstock. Lies. Wow.

I hope we do something about this. I know we've been working on it. This is really bad though.

I can't imagine that Rickenbacker or Fender (who owns Gretsch now) will stand for it. They'll do anything and everything to protect the brands.

Maybe they'll just stop retail, sell wholesale custom shop only, like ... I don't know. Carvin. \:\)


T57Strat
(Planeteer)
12/29/11 01:36 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Bottom line is up to the consumer. If it's too good to be true, it usually is. People buy this bullshit and they stay in business...

Silversmith
(Loquacious Planeteer)
12/29/11 01:58 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

if these things are being sold to the US (or Canada - or anywhere that has copyright laws), could they not be stopped at the boarder?

rhythmace47
(Planeteer)
12/29/11 02:07 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Counterfeit stuff. Huge problem these days. Fake is fake. It just gets back to all the stuff we choose to buy with no regard for the jobs lost here or the working conditions in other countries that people endure cranking stuff out. Same thing, different day. The traffic has gotten so heavy it's almost impossible to police it all.

Sad really. Everyone and his brother putting music online for free using counterfeit instruments. Then the purists out there saying stuff like...well, I have a copy of that really crappy song being played by those guys using real Fenders. So, basically, your recording is bogus and you just don't get real music when you hear it. Ha ha. Fucked up. All of it.


WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
12/29/11 02:07 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

These counterfeit guitars are showing up on craigslist now in Phoenix. Some of the sellers disclose that it's fake....others don't. I flag all the counterfeit guitar ads that I run across on CL. The ads don't usually last long.

But it's definitely "Buyer Beware" these days. You better know your shit when you are looking to buy a high priced used guitar these days on CL...



Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
12/29/11 02:49 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Quote:
There was a big article I recently read about this. There are Martin guitars out there now that have the C.F. Martin name, logos, the whole thing on it. They are made in China. And there is nothing that the real C.F. Martin Co. in Nazareth PA can do about it.

There is no such thing as patent law protection in China. There is absolutely nothing preventing Chinese manufacturers from stealing not only designs, but brand identities from reputable companies.

It appears this is one of them.

How brazen, the Gretsch White Falcon says "Made in the U.S.A." stamped in gold on the back of the headstock. Lies. Wow.

I hope we do something about this. I know we've been working on it. This is really bad though.

I can't imagine that Rickenbacker or Fender (who owns Gretsch now) will stand for it. They'll do anything and everything to protect the brands.

Maybe they'll just stop retail, sell wholesale custom shop only, like ... I don't know. Carvin.


Tom, Fender bought Gretsch circa the late 90’s.

Yeah, this is a messed up affair—the fact that patent laws can’t be enforced in China. However, there is an irony to all this as well. The advent of cheap labor in Asian countries is now proving to be a double edged sward for these companies, and these knockoffs will inevitably cut into their bottom line profits.

As a Gretsch guy myself, I was pissed off when they started manufacturing the cheaper Chinese models a few years back because I feel the Gretsch name, much like the Rickenbacker name, is one that carries a certain prestige. Now, it’s been cheapened with some “Squire-like” notion of an inexpensive version of the real deal, which really is nothing like the real deal in terms of playability and sound. If you want an inexpensive version of a 6120, for example, you’d do better with an Epi Casino, a Samick hollow body, or one of the Ibenez offerings IMO. Anyway, you get my point.

To date, I’ve never purchased an instrument on line, and with possibly the exception of buying a Jay Turser violin bass online from a reputable dealer, I probably never will. This is EXACTLY the reason why.

Chris


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
12/29/11 02:58 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Quote:
"Honesty and intergrity"


Hmmmm.... ...ok.


Yeah, that struck me too as ironic—that and the “God is first in our life” declaration. Notice all the improper grammar and misspellings too. That’s a sure fire sign that the company is not on the up and up.

Man, I’d love a White Falcon and a 4003 Firegloe or any number of the other guitar designs they rip off, and I wouldn’t even mind a fake version. That’s sort of the tragedy here because I would consider buying and trying one out if it weren’t for the fact they are blatantly counterfeiting other brands. Just change the logo, for crying out loud. The only possible reason they’re doing this is to market to other unscrupulous people who’d try to sell them at the market value of the real McCoy.

Which brings me to this question: There may not currently be any laws prohibiting Chinese manufacturers from doing this sort of thing, BUT can’t a U.S. citizen be prosecuted for knowingly pawning off counterfeit goods as the real deal? I think so.

Chris


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
12/29/11 08:40 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Speaking of cheap guitars, has anyone ever purchased anything form Rondo or Guitar Fetish. I’ve been watching both those companies now for a few years, and they seem reputable. I like the fact that they offer inexpensive guitars from generic manufacturers, like Agile and Xavier, while making no bones about what they actually are. People seem to like them. There are actually a lot of online reviews and Youtube reviews as well. Still, I just couldn’t bring myself to buy anything like that online without having first played it.

At some point in the next few months I will start gunning for another LP, since I sold my Gibson LP in early 07, but I’m not sold on Gibson. I’ll probably settle for a nice mahogany top from Greg Bennett/Samick or Epi. If I can find a Heritage at a reasonable price I may go that route too.

Point is there are lots of great options out there these days without having to resort to what amounts to intellectual rape. Companies like Yamaha, Cort, Samkick, Ibanez, and now some of the new brands, like Agile, all make good replicas of original models, with their own twists of course. Personally, I could give a crap about the name on the headstock…never has mattered to me very much…..All I care about is how it plays, how it sounds, how it feels, and maybe how it looks. Ironically enough, I would also care if my instrument had a counterfeit name on it because it just feels dirty. If I owned one of those “The Top Guitars” I’d have to shower every time I played it.

Chris


ulank
(Planeteer)
12/29/11 11:47 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Silversmith
could they not be stopped at the boarder?


You been watchin lotsa hockey up der, eh?



Hollweg will stop them!


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/08/16 06:38 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

hello everyone kolhauszer here i just joined today
i have been reading this old post and allow me to say that i myself have 3 guitars from top guitar.
it started out on kijiji and i saw a beautiful 1960 les paul,a beautiful angus young tribute and a beautiful 1963 les paul sg,,from the price i knew they were replicas,,so i contacted topguitar myself..they DO IN FACT have the rights to recreate gibsons but only vintage models as well as other named brands..the woods used are impeccable quality with no SCARF MOLDINGS whatsoever.the right weight the right feel,,okay with chinese parts but the also deal with world famous names as well like wilkensen and Seymour d's..i own a les paul traditional myself and she is my goddess of forever..but this is no copyright infrigments this in indeed allowed by gibsons and other named brands....or so my investigation has led me to this knowledge..as far as i see it being in the guitar making business,i feel they have no need to lie..but thats just me.

i hope this thread is still alive btw

i mean seeing that topguitars has been in the business now since 2000,i dont see any reason for them to lie about anything..
but my 3 beauties are indeed 1 level down from the real deal..and they have so many AMAZING testimonies from so many happy clients and customers..

im not advocating theft.nor am i a spokesperson.i wouldnt know how to be 1 lol..just a bit of my take
thanks all


gonzo
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/08/16 06:54 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

zombie thread.

motown59
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 07:14 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

"Cicadas have prominent eyes set wide apart, short antennae, and membranous front wings. They have an exceptionally loud song, produced not by stridulation but by vibrating drumlike tymbals rapidly. The periodic cicadas spend most of their lives as underground nymphs, only emerging most likely to reduce losses by satiating their predators."

WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 07:22 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Sniff, sniff.

It smells a little spammy in here.

Do I need to get out Maxwell's silver ban hammer?



motown59
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 07:26 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

"has been in the business now since 2000,i dont see any reason for them to lie about anything.."

Two letters for you:
VW


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/08/16 08:00 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

hmm lol well i have no idea what vw means..seeing that it was not explained then i see that my efforts and explanations has meant nothing..ill know better then to join next time
thanks just the same


but yeah zombie thread for sure..but i felt it was my obligation to inform others that topguitar does have consent to replicate
and that although nothing beats a real gibson,,and most of us would prefer to buy a real beauty,,but the ones i have from top guitars are indeed second to none


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/08/16 08:15 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

WTF?!?....since this was originally my thread from some 5 plus years ago I'm going to chime in and say this: Just because a small Chinese company like this is able to get around international trademark laws or whatever doesn't make it right, and I would never do business with a company that operated this way....it's a violation of intellectual property...If Top Guitars wants to make guitars then let them come up with their own trademarks and logos.....what they're doing is deceptive and people buying them in order to put them back out on the open market for resale to unsuspecting buyers--trying to pass them off as legitimate Gibsons, Fenders, Gretsch's, etc--are being dishonest.

I bet dollars to donuts they play and sound like shit too.....I'll take a genuine Epi or Squire any day over some cheap forgery job or any forgery job, for that matter.


WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 08:23 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I find it very hard to believe that Gibson, Fender, and other major guitar manufacturers have given their consent to allow cheap counterfeit copies be made in China with Gibson/Fender/etc. on the headstock.

Mooseboy
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/08/16 08:40 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Kill the zombie! \:D

Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/08/16 08:52 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Wish
I find it very hard to believe that Gibson, Fender, and other major guitar manufacturers have given their consent to allow cheap counterfeit copies be made in China with Gibson/Fender/etc. on the headstock.


That's because that's not the truth. The truth is if they're still selling guitars with other manufacturer's logos then they're operating illegally. The only reason they haven't been shutdown is because they're operating "between the lines' of international law, probably off the coast of China somewhere....btw, I do seem to recall reading somewhere sometime back ago that they were shutdown at one point.....Are they still selling guitars with other logos?

I looked up their reviews, and it doesn't get any sketchier than this. Their top endorser is some self-important internet YouTube rapper from 2013, who praises The Top Guitars for how "great" they are but never once shows the viewer the fucking instrument.....other videos are very similar...just some nobody talking about how great the guitar is on is GoPro, but you never get a good look at the guitar itself...God forbid you ever get to hear a sound clip...In 2016 if you don't have more than that then you're full of shit!


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 08:53 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

As long as it doesn't have the actual brand name on the headstock, I don't care.
But when it does, that crosses the line to me.

I mean, I have "one-offs" that are based closely on brand names, so who am I to say?
But they don't have Fender or Gibson or......on the headstock.

Anyway, this is all old news.....been going on for years.
Gibson Les Pauls have been the most bastardized.

If you have a problem, speak wit your wallet and JUST SAY NO!....and buy an Epiphone, Gibson Jr, or PRS SE, or made in Indonesia Fender, etc.

But then, an Epiphone is no different than these no-name imports.

Whatever floats your boat (personally, I won't buy one).


Xenophile
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 08:57 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: kolhauszer
it was my obligation to inform others that topguitar does have consent to replicate


Just like Apple gave their consent for the marketing of this "iPoo." At least in this case they changed one letter.



MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 09:04 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Wish
I find it very hard to believe that Gibson, Fender, and other major guitar manufacturers have given their consent to allow cheap counterfeit copies be made in China with Gibson/Fender/etc. on the headstock.

They haven't.
It's a hard fight to win on foreign territory where the morals/ethics are as low as the prices.

How did this spambot get in here?

Sorry, in my last post, I didn't read through I didn't realize this was a thread from 1962.


Mooseboy
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/08/16 09:27 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: MadGuitrst
…But then, an Epiphone is no different than these no-name imports…
Sir, I take umbrage at that statement! Your ignorance is showing


AL
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/08/16 09:30 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

heh welcome to the top guitar rep.

Mooseboy
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/08/16 09:50 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Back at MG:



Rob Chapman, who knows WAY more about guitars than you (or me), is totally guessing in a true blindfold test.


motown59
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 10:13 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: MadGuitrst

But then, an Epiphone is no different than these no-name imports.

Whatever floats your boat (personally, I won't buy one).


I totally understand that. What an Epiphone is now, is a copy of Gibson but a sanctioned one. Gibson has overseen the process of copying their guitars.

Same with a Squier Strat.

That concept alone might be uncomfortable for some. But for the companies, these sub lines make business sense: to have price points with the branding still intact. It's always easier to expand downward from a more prestigious respected position.

So, if you're uncomfortable with Epiphones these unlicensed copies with the respected original parent name, and no cue that they're copies..feels a bit sketchy


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/08/16 10:29 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Im curious to know what Gibson did with the Kramer line since they bought them out, or are they leaving them to run independently. I have a pre-gibson Kramer. Plays and sounds really nice.

kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/08/16 11:39 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

okydok..my conscience is clear either way..
i guess it would not bother anyone to know that they even have a manufactering plant in arizona?..and as mentioned they also use wilkensen bridges seymour pick ups etc..they have korean plants and american ones.yes i know that china has no patent protection laws,but how can they operate in america if they did not have the rights?..and hell no..the sound coming from the topguitar les paul standard may be different then my real les paul traditional..that has burstbuckers while the standard has seymours..but the same woods used for both are equal..and the feel and the weight are equal,a guitar store owner friend of mine for the last 5 years knew that the three topguitars i got from kijiji were replicas but he was very impresed at the quality,the sounds,,the wood,,the feel everything


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/08/16 11:42 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

not trying to cause a war..
i was trying to say that they are legit..unless of course the entire website is a lie and the man i spoke to is a lier..but i feel the plant in arizona would be shut down and sued if this was indeed illegal..just saying


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/08/16 11:53 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

here we go..from the F.A.Q SECTION of their website..
many are indeed assembled in america.
------------------------------------------------
-Where Does the Products come from?
Korea Custom Shop Guitars and Basses - Assembled in RPC; Electronic Components and Wood are imported from Japan and Korea to ensure the best quality performance

USA Custom Shop Guitars - Assembled in Tampa, Florida

Authorized USA Brand Guitars - From USA Manufacturer

Authorized Cecilio Musical Instruments - From USA Manufacturer ( Los Angeles, California )--------------------------------------------

so i ask again..how can many customs and parts be assembled in the states if this was illegal?


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/09/16 12:04 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

crap,,lol i posted a section of th f.a.q section on top guitars . com..it explains how many custom made guitars and parts are created in tampa florida..but vs planet removed it..i joined vs planet this afternoon to say to my fellow jammerheads here that even though top guitars legally makes gibsons and other named brands with very top quality,,but also to say that after being a 29 year player of gibsons,there is nothing to fear,,the greatest name in guitar history will never be outdone..they said the same thing about paul reed smith as well however lol lol

kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/09/16 12:06 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

ohhh no sorry its on this page lol

WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:07 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

From the same FAQ:

Why are prices so affordable?

We build all our guitars from scratch at our own factory overseas. We sell all our guitars directly to you (the end user). This means you get factory-direct pricing because there are no 3rd party guitar manufacturers, distributors, dealers, or other middlemen between you and us.


How Long Does Delivery Take?

For United Kingdom: 5 – 7 Business days from China to United Kingdom. United Kingdom Customs will usually hold the package for 5 – 10 Business days. Estimated time to receive the guitar is 12 – 15 Business days after dispatch. For Delivery Delays inquiries, please contact your Local Post Office immediately. You may track your package via http://www.parcelforce.com

For United States: 5 – 7 Business days from China to United States. United States Customs will usually hold the package for 5 – 10 Business days. Estimated time to receive the guitar is 12 – 15 Business days after dispatch. For Delivery Delays inquiries, please contact your Local Post Office immediately. You may track your package http://www.usps.com

For Other Countries: 10 - 12 Business days from China to Country of Destination. Government Customs will usually hold the package for 10 – 12 Business days. Estimated time to receive the guitar is 15-20 Business days after dispatch. For Delivery Delays inquiries, please contact your Local Post Office immediately.


WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:08 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

It appears to me that all of the guitars are made and shipped from China.



fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:10 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Did they steal the serial numbers too?

WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:10 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

And the brand names are counterfeit.

kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/09/16 12:29 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

oh..lol..then i guess i got it all wrong
actually i only learned about all this yesturday morning i knew that they were chinese made for sure..but from their website and the communication with a representative from topguitars that i spoke to i really assumed i was right..then im guessing that the topguitar NON replicas are made in the states only?..no worries,i had good intentions

later jammers

im trying to send you all a picture of the three but i cant figure out how


WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:39 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

You have to host the picture on another site like photobucket and then link to it with [img] tags.

Unfortunately, we don't host pictures on VSPlanet.


Mooseboy
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:43 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Wish, would you mind banning this troll?

fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:50 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?



WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:58 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I actually believe he is legit at this point, and not a spammer.



WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 12:58 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

He is Canadian. What can you do????

;\)


fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 01:01 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Build a wall and make him pay for it?

WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 01:04 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

We could build the wall with fake Chinese guitars.

fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 01:05 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

\:D

glensimonds
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 01:53 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

i saw that website fake as hell they show pictures of the real thing and say those are ones they are selling it's a facebook add, i'm surprised facebook lets them put it up there

WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 01:59 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

We should all try to build bridges, instead of walls.



fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 01:59 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?



glensimonds
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 02:05 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

good fences make good neighbors

MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 06:01 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

MB, I don't have a problem with Epiphone - you took my statement wrong (or I said it wrong).
I own four of them and love them all.

2 Les Pauls - one that I'd put against any LP.


SG and it is the best playing SG I've ever laid my hands on.
Epiphone Casino that is just pure fun.


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 08:13 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Mooseboy
Rob Chapman, who knows WAY more about guitars than you (or me)

Really?

I currently own more than 60 guitars and have owned over 100 and probably played thousands.

I think I know a thing or two about guitars....but maybe 47 years of experience playing and all of the guitars I own, have modified, and have played are meaningless. ;\)


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 08:27 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: MadGuitrst
 Originally Posted By: Mooseboy
Rob Chapman, who knows WAY more about guitars than you (or me)

Really?

I currently own more than 60 guitars and have owned over 100 and probably played thousands.

I think I know a thing or two about guitars....but maybe 47 years of experience playing and all of the guitars I own, have modified, and have played are meaningless. ;\)



Rob Chapman has his own brand of guitars. http://www.chapmanguitars.co.uk


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 08:31 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: drhek2004
Rob Chapman has his own brand of guitars. http://www.chapmanguitars.co.uk

Very nice looking guitars!


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 08:55 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Never played one. Look well made. They have middle of the road prices.

https://www.riffcityguitaroutlet.com/collections/chapman-guitars?gclid=CKu_jK2ds8sCFQERaQod5K0Dwg


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/09/16 01:35 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I’ve owned three Epiphones in the past and really liked all of them. I had an ES 335 (Korean, pre DOT series), a Joe Pass, and the original Hell Kat series. In 2012 I sold the last one of them to buy something else, but I’d have no problem owning another Epiphone. I probably will at some point.

But I’m not a guitar collector, although I’ve had as many as 20 or so at a time. I prefer to have a few go-tos in my arsenal that I’m intricately familiar with and that become an extension of my body. You can’t really do that if you’re playing 20 different guitars at a time. And if you’re not playing all of them, then they’re just sitting in a case or hanging on a wall collecting dust…..what’s the point of that?....plus, the upkeep and setup become cost prohibitive at some point too…..I currently have 5 electric six strings, and while I may grab another LP, Pro Jet, and Tele Thinline down the road, I don’t want more than 7 or 8 tops.

Anyway and back to point, if Kolhauszer is confident about the quality of his Top Guitar (counterfeit piece of junk) why doesn’t he do what any of us would do and post some close up pictures and some sound clips?....I want to see it and hear it, not because I’d ever buy one but because I’m just curious to see how “good” they may be. Not all counterfeits are bad replications, but from an ethical standpoint that’s not the point. However, from a sonic standpoint, I’m all ears. Let’s see and hear it.

I can’t get to The Top Guitars website from this server and didn’t have a chance last night to view it at home. But from what I remember seeing years ago I got the impression they lifted stock photos of the genuine guitar logos they were ripping off and using them as examples of their own guitar builds. Who knows? That’s the disturbing thing. And they’ve been in business (illegally, mind you) for years now, and yet, there’s not one single YouTube video or any other independent review that gives potential buyers a detailed description or review of the product/s….not one!.....These guys make Behringer look like saints.


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/09/16 07:22 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

thanks wish for believing that i am legit .after all when i received my topguitars replicas,and wanted to learn more about topguitars,i joined vs planet because i saw this sideline post.and wanted to share witk my fellow jammerheads what i knew
thanks wish
yup im canadian..and im very new to this internet jazz,i spend most of my time being retired,golfing,fishing and jamming with the brothers,so i have no idea what a troll is aside from the mythical creature..so you can trash me down as much as you wish
mouseboy,still got nothing against ya
gibson lovers are part of one of the largest brotherhood in the world,and youre a brother too...but why pick a name like mouseboy? just curious


gonzo
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/09/16 07:50 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

i've always considered EPIPHONE as being the place that up and coming luthiers cut their teeth before moving on up to either GIBSON, or other....

every epiphone i've ever played has been a quality guitar.

some, have been better than the model it is copying....

the Epiphone_Gibson connection is quite clear.
it's not the same thing as a 'replica',
and was never positioned that way from a marketing aspect.


gonzo
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/09/16 07:55 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

case in point:



i have this guitar in the studio right now...
and used it for several tracks on the most recent album..

this guitar is a FRACTION of the cost of a real gibby doubleneck,
but the sound, playability, quality of craftsmanship is all there.

it is a bolt on neck, NOT a glue in long tenon construction.


http://www.musiciansfriend.com/guitars/e...L4MF-adType^PLA

999.00


http://www.americanmusical.com/Item--i-G...CFQmRaQodRxkMnw
$6499.00



can you hear/feel the diff?
yea, a little bit.

put a cost on 'a little bit'


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/09/16 08:08 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

hey excellent example gonzo
she is a beauty
the beauties i recieved from the kijiji guy who bought them from topguitars has absolutely no signs of scarf moldings at all..top quality woods.i had a 2001 prs singlecut 10 top awhile back.and i am still so impressed with the quality that i sent topguitars all the specs of my 2001,i just have to swab out for a set of 5708s and its just like having her back again..of course its more of a missing her kind of thing,,and at 980 us its not given away..
i wish i could figure out all this sharing the pictures jazz..i will though and thanks for the info up there wish..ill get my neohew to help me do it..


Mooseboy
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/09/16 08:16 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

MG, yes it was Chappys guitar company that made me say he knows more about guitars than both of us. And he's quite the player when he's not just goofing around.

47 years, eh? That's about three or four less than me.

Anyway, I definitely misunderstood your earlier post, as it looks like you're quite the Epi fan, too!

Cheers bro!


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 08:27 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Im liking this model of his.



MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/09/16 08:53 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Mooseboy

Cheers bro!

Cheers indeed, my friend!


kolhauszer
(Space Cadet)
03/09/16 09:44 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

well like i mentioned gretch i do have a authentic les paul traditional,yes ive always known they were replicas..and at a minimum of 980 dollars us with the best tone woods id hardly consider them pieces of junk ..i simply wanted to shsre,,but i see now that at my age this has been a mistake on my part..i'll leave internet chatting for the younger crowd..

thanks for having me on wish..keep jamming people


gonzo
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/09/16 10:12 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

it's got absolutely nothing to do with age.

keep seeking the truth.


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 12:47 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

My Epi SG is made in Korea and looks just like this....with aged binding and trapezoid inlays and the awesome set up with super low action.



fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 12:49 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

What are those pups about? They look a tad cheesy, just sayin'.

MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 01:03 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

It's the plastic covers, like on a pickguard....only with wordsm that you're seeing.

WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 01:06 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

This guitar is brand new.

They just have that protective plastic on them to protect the pups from scratches....the plastic has writing on it, which is why they look a bit odd....The plastic will be peeled off by the purchaser of the guitar.


WishAdministrator
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 01:06 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

D'oh....too late.

fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 01:07 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Oh ok, they kinda had that Sears kinda look haha.

Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 02:34 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: kolhauszer
well like i mentioned gretch i do have a authentic les paul traditional,yes ive always known they were replicas..and at a minimum of 980 dollars us with the best tone woods id hardly consider them pieces of junk ..i simply wanted to shsre,,but i see now that at my age this has been a mistake on my part..i'll leave internet chatting for the younger crowd..

thanks for having me on wish..keep jamming people


Hey man, here's the deal: I've also owned a genuine Gibson LP that I held onto for about 16 years before selling it and a Gibson ES 335 (1972) that I had in my possession at one time. I've owned and played more guitars than I could possibly cite. I've been playing for almost 31 years, much of that time either semi pro or professionally. I also worked at a mom and pop guitar shop for about 10 years as a second job. I know enough about the lay of the land to know this: That "tone wood" you're referring doesn't come from the same location from which Gibson acquires their's. At best, it may be on par with other Chinese manufacturers, and that process has come a long way in the past 15 years...no doubt...however, although those woods may sound good in their own right, they're not "the same.".....just say'n.....what you have is essentially an Epiphone knockoff with a counterfeit logo on the head stock and a sketchy business history...by "sketchy" I mean the CEO better not ever set foot outside the territory they're operating out of because he'll likely be arrested.


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 02:37 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: MadGuitrst
My Epi SG is made in Korea and looks just like this....with aged binding and trapezoid inlays and the awesome set up with super low action.



Someone told me (fonts) that was a The Top Guitars guitar.....I don't know...just say'n....


Mooseboy
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 02:55 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Sigh… I sure wish that an SG would work for me, because I sure love the look.

Chimp
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 04:01 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I have a friend who bought a Santana Knock of PRS even signed by Paul. It has Epiphone pick up's in it and the tailpiece is not a PRS tailpiece.

Epiphone pick ups are not the same as Gibsons. My old guitar player shwitched his to Gibson for a notable tone improvement.

I have a few Epi's they are fine instruments.


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 04:55 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Gretsch 6120
Someone told me (fonts) that was a The Top Guitars guitar.....I don't know...just say'n....

Well, they do make SGs (and seemingly everything else) but:

I paid $300.00 for mine brand new with a hardshell case - they are charging $550.75 with shipping even with a $100 discount.

I got to play mine before buying it, which is why I bought it \:D .

Also, I checked out their Les Pauls.

The cost is $715 with shipping, even with a $100 discount.

I paid $250 with Gibson case for the Epiphone Les Paul I have pictured in this thread.
It was used but in pristine shape.
It has a one piece mahogany back, not two or three, which is an upcharge from Top Guitars.

And so, I can buy a known quantity for less money and live with myself because Top Guitars are indeed putting brand names on their headstocks and are fraudulent.

It does look like they can do offer nice work, as do many Chinese builders, but frankly, you can buy for WAY less money direct from China because Top Guitars is a middleman.

http://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-les-paul.html

http://www.aliexpress.com/item/less-high...08.4.104.BRbbjr

There ya go.....$325 to your door for a "Less Paul".


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 12:45 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

"Is it Illegal to Buy Counterfeit Goods?

In the U.S., federal law protecting trademarks makes it illegal to knowingly traffic counterfeit goods, which includes the production, sale and transport of such goods. The U.S. Department of Justice, however, has stated that federal law doesn’t prohibit an individual from buying a counterfeit product for personal use, even if they do so knowingly."

http://consumer.findlaw.com/consumer-transactions/buying-counterfeit-goods-laws-and-resources.html


Getting a fake with a fake name is just for vanity reasons. In the 80s when I played out alot, I definitely would have gotten a number of those fakes, from Gibsons to Jacksons, Play a different one for each song in the list! That would definitely look pro, wouldnt it? \:D EG. Doing Ozzy covers, use the Polkidot V


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 01:59 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: drhek2004
"Is it Illegal to Buy Counterfeit Goods?

In the U.S., federal law protecting trademarks makes it illegal to knowingly traffic counterfeit goods, which includes the production, sale and transport of such goods. The U.S. Department of Justice, however, has stated that federal law doesn’t prohibit an individual from buying a counterfeit product for personal use, even if they do so knowingly."

http://consumer.findlaw.com/consumer-transactions/buying-counterfeit-goods-laws-and-resources.html


Getting a fake with a fake name is just for vanity reasons. In the 80s when I played out alot, I definitely would have gotten a number of those fakes, from Gibsons to Jacksons, Play a different one for each song in the list! That would definitely look pro, wouldnt it? \:D EG. Doing Ozzy covers, use the Polkidot V


It looks pretentious to me, personally. Even if the guitars are legit, I hate that whole "look at me, I'm a rock star" bullshit......My stage persona has always been more of a down to Earth type. If I'm in control and owning the moment and stage then no one should give a shit about the insignia on my guitar's headstock.....I've played plenty of shows with an Epi and received plenty of positive feedback......My main axes today are an American Fender Strat, Tele, and a Gretsch 6120....I certainly have no excuse not to sound "pro.".....If I fall short it ain't the guitar....but that has always been my philosophy, whether I'm playing a Gibson, and Epi, a Fender, or a Gretsch....


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 02:03 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: MadGuitrst
 Originally Posted By: Gretsch 6120
Someone told me (fonts) that was a The Top Guitars guitar.....I don't know...just say'n....

Well, they do make SGs (and seemingly everything else) but:

I paid $300.00 for mine brand new with a hardshell case - they are charging $550.75 with shipping even with a $100 discount.

I got to play mine before buying it, which is why I bought it \:D .

Also, I checked out their Les Pauls.

The cost is $715 with shipping, even with a $100 discount.

I paid $250 with Gibson case for the Epiphone Les Paul I have pictured in this thread.
It was used but in pristine shape.
It has a one piece mahogany back, not two or three, which is an upcharge from Top Guitars.

And so, I can buy a known quantity for less money and live with myself because Top Guitars are indeed putting brand names on their headstocks and are fraudulent.

It does look like they can do offer nice work, as do many Chinese builders, but frankly, you can buy for WAY less money direct from China because Top Guitars is a middleman.

http://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-les-paul.html

http://www.aliexpress.com/item/less-high...08.4.104.BRbbjr

There ya go.....$325 to your door for a "Less Paul".


I hope their factory burns down. That's a nice looking SG. Like Mosseboy, they just never caught on with me. I could dig one for rhythm duty, but I've never played one that made me want to take it home to make it my main axe...to each his own.


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 02:10 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Chimp
I have a friend who bought a Santana Knock of PRS even signed by Paul. It has Epiphone pick up's in it and the tailpiece is not a PRS tailpiece.

Epiphone pick ups are not the same as Gibsons. My old guitar player shwitched his to Gibson for a notable tone improvement.

I have a few Epi's they are fine instruments.


This is true regarding the superior Gibson pickups, especially in years prior. A lot of Epiphones modern guitars, however, ranging in the $300 and up price point, are using superior electronics and higher end Duncan's from what I've gleaned. Of course, those pickups won't sound "the same" as the Gibson counterparts, but "better" or "worse" is a matter of subjectivity in some cases.

I've said it before many times, and I'll say it again: Gibson's have long bee way overpriced. In many cases companies like Epiphone or Sammick provide an equal or even superior overall product for a fraction of the price, and with the money you save you can put any pickups in those guitars you want and still have money left in your pocket.

I've played some really nice Gibsons, and I've played some really crappy ones too, right out the box. A $1,500 guitar should not have fret issues and terrible intonation right out of the factor, not to mention ones I've seen with cosmetic laws and no discount for them. Gibson's QA has suffered a lot over the years, while their pricing would reflect they're the top dogs in quality. There's a disconnect there IME.


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 06:13 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Yeah, the newer versions are using copies of their own Gibson pickups, which might be the same maker(s) of Duncan Designed (I have no idea).

The bottom line is that the electronics have gotten better just as have the instruments.

Also, Grover tuners and not crap on some of them.

FWIW, I changed the PUs on the SG I have....too harsh and grainy....put the PUs on both Epi LPs sound really, really good to me, although they stray a bit out of the PAF range (more bite and traction, not that I don't love good old PAF types).

And you're right about the crappy (name brand here), Chris.
That's mostly because the large box stores do NO setup on their guitars.....blows my mind.

The day I got that Epi SG, I bought four guitars (I traded two shredders in....one Ibanez, one Charvel): Epi SG, Epi Casino, Gibson Les Paul Doublecut Faded (P90s), and a Gibson LP Jr (single P90).

ALL of the guitars were setup VERY well (especially that SG, it's like butter) because they came from one of the few remaining mom and pop stores and they DID FUCKING SETUPS ON THEIR GUITARS!!!!

Sheesh.....

I know there are inherent qualities and flaws in any instrument, but setup, by someone very good, is key.


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 06:20 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Weren't you wanting to start a Stryper tribute band? No problem!

http://www.aliexpress.com/item/jackson-f...16-86fce090502d


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 06:55 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Stop!.....I got dizzy looking at that thing!

Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 08:01 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: drhek2004
Weren't you wanting to start a Stryper tribute band? No problem!

http://www.aliexpress.com/item/jackson-f...16-86fce090502d


Who?


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 08:11 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: MadGuitrst
Yeah, the newer versions are using copies of their own Gibson pickups, which might be the same maker(s) of Duncan Designed (I have no idea).

The bottom line is that the electronics have gotten better just as have the instruments.

Also, Grover tuners and not crap on some of them.

FWIW, I changed the PUs on the SG I have....too harsh and grainy....put the PUs on both Epi LPs sound really, really good to me, although they stray a bit out of the PAF range (more bite and traction, not that I don't love good old PAF types).

And you're right about the crappy (name brand here), Chris.
That's mostly because the large box stores do NO setup on their guitars.....blows my mind.

The day I got that Epi SG, I bought four guitars (I traded two shredders in....one Ibanez, one Charvel): Epi SG, Epi Casino, Gibson Les Paul Doublecut Faded (P90s), and a Gibson LP Jr (single P90).

ALL of the guitars were setup VERY well (especially that SG, it's like butter) because they came from one of the few remaining mom and pop stores and they DID FUCKING SETUPS ON THEIR GUITARS!!!!

Sheesh.....

I know there are inherent qualities and flaws in any instrument, but setup, by someone very good, is key.


I've told this story before, but many years ago, sometime back around 04/05 as I recall, we had a brand new Gibson LP Pro, if I remember correctly, come into the shop for a setup. It was brand spanking new, just out of the box. The store's guitar luthier was a really talented kid at the time and son of the owner, who built his own guitars and started his own guitar building company in the back of the shop. His name is Jake. He did setup work for his dad on the side. We were buds, and when I was in between teaching lessons one day Jake pulled me in the back and showed me the LP they'd just brought in, right out of the box. Not only was the action ridiculously high when it came in, but the frets were jacked up and needed to be dressed. Although I don't remember the exact series, this was one of the higher end Gibsons. It was an $1,800 guitar at the time, at least, and I remember thinking "what's the point of that?"

We were Samick and Cort dealers at the time, also carrying some of the Fender lines then, and we rarely saw any of even the lower end guitars come in that bad of shape, and if they did they'd be sent back.

That said, I don't begrudge Gibson for their genius branding. They apparently have no problem selling their guitars, and good on them. But unless I just come across another awesome deal on a real Gibson, I'm probably not going to buy one again. I bought my last Gibson LP for $200 off a friend in high school that was going to pawn it for that to buy weed. I gave him cash for it, and some 15 years or so later I sold it for $1,300 and could have gotten a lot more had I been greedy. I thought for sure it would sit in the shop on consignment for a few weeks. It wasn't there for two days before two dudes started bidding on it.


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/10/16 08:27 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Gretsch 6120
 Originally Posted By: drhek2004
Weren't you wanting to start a Stryper tribute band? No problem!

http://www.aliexpress.com/item/jackson-f...16-86fce090502d


Who?



MG ;\)


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/10/16 08:38 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

MG was a Stryper fan?...who knew? ...I can't picture him in yellow and black spandex with big fluffy hair.....don't want to picture it either.... \:p

MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/11/16 02:52 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Gretsch 6120
don't want to picture it either.... \:p

That makes two of us.


fabulousthunderbird
(Planeteer)
03/11/16 02:54 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Gretsch 6120
 Originally Posted By: MadGuitrst
My Epi SG is made in Korea and looks just like this....with aged binding and trapezoid inlays and the awesome set up with super low action.



Someone told me (fonts) that was a The Top Guitars guitar.....I don't know...just say'n....


Huh? I don't recall that.

My '84 Gibson is to die for.


Chimp
(Planeteer)
03/11/16 03:24 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I have a Gibson Robot SG that's only a couple of years old - It is a killer f'n guitar. Bought it new for $700.00!!

Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/11/16 01:18 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: Chimp
I have a Gibson Robot SG that's only a couple of years old - It is a killer f'n guitar. Bought it new for $700.00!!


There are a lot of really nice Gibsons, no doubt, and in recent years some of them have been manufactured overseas.....If you look at the label and specs, though, they're up front about which ones are U.S. and which ones are Chinese built.


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/11/16 08:13 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

NO REAL Gibsons are made oversees, especially in China.
If you know different and can provide a link that would be very interesting.

Chris, where did you get that idea?

The only Gibson owned guitars made oversees are named Epiphone.

If you see a Gibson that was made in China it's a Chibson - counterfeit.
Period.


Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
03/11/16 08:35 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Nope, you're right. For some reason I thought the Melody Maker and some of the lower end Gibsons were being manufactured at the same location as the Epiphones,...probably some bullshit I read back during the Gibson manufacturing plant raids of 2012 or so.....but that's backwards I think....Some of the Epiphones--or at least it used to be the case with the Custom Epis--are/were made in the Gibson plant.

Then again, I ran across 2016 LP Studio....It has wood almost certainly sourced from Asia that will love you long time. Also, when you go to buy it they won't accept U.S. currency, only yin....So......just keep that in mind....


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/11/16 09:39 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

It's the stain finish on the maple that's confusing you.

Not much wood that's used for guitars come from China, certainly not maple or mahogany.

That's why the Chibsons are made from alterna-woods (not that they're bad) and thin veneers for figured tips (again, not bad, just not the receipt for a real Gibson).

Woods from Asia typically are senn-ash, pawlonia, and basswood, etc.
All are good wood for guitars, just not the Gibson, or even Fender, recipe.

For my knowledge on woods -traditional and what's considered alternative(s), is extensive.

I could show you some pms with t57strat regarding this and have contacts in Africa, Madagascar, and other places as it was something I was considering in perusing with t57strat and his partner Kerry (we were even down to deciding on a CNC machine, etc.)


Chimp
(Planeteer)
03/11/16 11:54 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

The Robot was built in Nashville \:\)

Chimp
(Planeteer)
03/12/16 12:02 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Out of Mahogany by the way!

MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
03/12/16 02:54 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Out of Hundoran mahogany but there are others (African, etc.) and woods considered in a similar family or at least nature and somewhat interchangably (Sapele, Spanish Cedar, etc.)

http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/mahogany-mixups-the-lowdown/

Not to mention, linba is pretty much readily available.


drhek2004
(Planeteer)
03/12/16 03:07 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

EVH Wolfgang Stealth (copy) for $174. This is sick.




This guy reviews a bunch of those chinese copies.


gretschdog
(Space Cadet)
02/10/19 08:44 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I contacted this company last night. I asked them about their legitimacy, and they blocked me from the website. Being a lefty, and with very few options to choose from, I was surprised at what they had to offer, then immediately became suspicious when I saw the prices. A lot of the details on their guitars are just a bit off, and you will notice, there a very few close up pics of the head stocks. A lot are obvious fakes, like the Rics. They are hideous. But some seem passable....until you see the prices. Since they refused to answer my honest questions, and blocked me from the site, Id say STAY WAY CLEAR. Their Facebook page is pure propaganda, and you cant comment on their YouTube videos. Very fishy !!

gretschdog
(Space Cadet)
02/10/19 08:46 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I forgot to mention.....RIGHT handed Bigsbys on the LEFT handed "Gretsch" guitars....!!!

Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
02/10/19 10:12 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Holy time warp, Batmam!!!...how the hell did this thread get resurrected?...I thought or assumed Top Guitars had shifted under a different name and was selling direct via facebook and the like....

flatcatAdministrator
(Loquacious Planeteer)
02/11/19 06:21 AM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

I was just looking at the "Rickenbacker 4001" and noticed that the headstock is upside-down. On a real one, the little curl is on the top, not the bottom. Also, a dot neck?!





Memphis Monroe
(Loquacious Planeteer)
02/11/19 03:13 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

Good eye, Flat....I'm surprised this "company" is still in business.....of course, now there are countless direct from China shops that advertise on social media and that offer everything counterfeit one could ever imagine.

Personally, at this point I wouldn’t even bother…..thing is companies like Squire and Epiphone have the best value instruments already dialed in, and I’d much rather have a genuine Squire than a counterfeit Ric or anything else…..

A couple years ago I ran across a SDOTD on musiciansfriend for a Squire Dimension Pro bass, which I guess is Fender’s/Squire’s answer to Musicman’s basses. The damn thing was $179 and usually retails for around $350. Let me tell you it was the BEST gamble and $179 I’ve ever spent on any instrument, high end, low end, or otherwise. Didn’t need anything, but I had a slight setup done and slapped on some Black Beauties. Now, it sounds and plays like an absolute dream. I don’t even consider myself a bass player, but I’m constantly getting compliments from the sound guy, other stage musicians, and congregation members at the church where I play on how great the tone is. The neck and maple fretboard alone is worth $179, and there’s nothing on that bass I’d change or modify. I keep looking at some higher end Fender PJ basses, but given how great this bass is, I can’t really justify it. I’ve played plenty of American and Mexican Fender P basses and a handful of J basses over the years from various companies. I’ve never played anything south of 5 bills that played or sounded this good….it’s ridiculous….

Point being, companies like Squire are killing it, and pro-sumers can now buy pro level gear for a budget price. Why in the hell would anyone want to waste their hard earned money on a blatant knockoff with no real name to stand behind it?


MadGuitrst
(Planeteer)
02/11/19 04:42 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?

 Originally Posted By: flatcat
I was just looking at the "Rickenbacker 4001" and noticed that the headstock is upside-down. On a real one, the little curl is on the top, not the bottom.

That's because, I'm sure you know, the headstock shape is the one thing that is trademark protected.

 Originally Posted By: flatcat
Also, a dot neck?!

Also, the fretboard in not finished, like with Rics. Bot might be better in this situation.

Anyway, I just looked that Ric over and a few thoughts:
I wanted to see if it was neck through, like a Ric. It is stated that it is but I couldn't see the lines/wings, except on the headstock. But you should be able to see them on the back of the body. On the order page, there are two options: 2 or 3 piece body ($45 up-charge for the 2 piece), with 3 piece as standard. That can't be with a neck through (well, it could be a million pieces but I think you know what I mean). That doesn't mean a 3 piece body that is glued in isn't ok, just not the same as a Ric.

Oh, I just saw that they have a neck-through option for $40.

On the picture on the website, the body is obviously basswood. It's a good wood and I like it for bass, but it's not a Ric, which is maple. The do offer a maple "body" for only a $20 up-charge, but who knows what you'd get. The concern I would have with basswood is neck dive.

The other up-charges are curious, to say the least. The fretboard wood options are interesting.

So, with options for Ric type construction and wood, up-graded pots, and a case, it costs $1,028. Take off a $120 coupon but add on $115 for shipping and you have $1,143.00, not exactly the sale of the century.

You could buy one direct from china at AliExpress for around the $300-$400 mark (shipped....maybe less, I didn't look or ask but have dealt directly with China in the past) and do the upgrades yourself and NOT have the Ric logo on it.

You know, it seems pretty obvious that this company is involved with the manufacturing and possible the QC is good. But there are already companies that do this and for less money. There is one out in CA that states up front where the instruments are made, does QC and setup, and has a return policy. They don't used the company's names, but they are copying designs (a lot of PRS clones). So then, why not a PRS SE? Seems like a no brainer.

There are a couple a companies completely making guitars here in the US with quality components for good prices, and others doing a sort of hybrid, that is buying parts overseas but assembling/setting up here in the US. I haven't played any of them but know of the. AT least they offer some recourse in the case something is not right ... and they up front, are not putting Made In The U.S.A. or the company names on the headstock. Here's one of them, Here's another .

Bottom line(s) for me:

It would be hypocritical for most to have an issue with the copy of guitar designs ONLY because Fender and Gibson has had their designs copied for years, especially by boutique builders, many of whom do built a better mousetrap...sometimes....and usually at a higher price, sometimes MUCH higher.

Some of those boutique builders are now seeing their "designs" being copied!

I would never, ever buy a guitar from Asia that has made in the USA on it and with the F or G logo. Never. AT least people have been educated on what to look for in the clones (obvious and not so obvious).

You CAN get a well made instrument from any of the Asia countries. Indonesia seemed to be the last place left and the bottom of the barrel but they have a long history of instrument making. But any of the countries can make a good instrument (or trash). Why not buy an F type guitar that's actually F?

Or, how about buying a Samick or Agile? Now, Top Customs Guitars might be made in the same factories and make as good or better instruments (it seems like they run the gambit), but for me, the simple fact that they use Mad In U.S.A is a total deal breaker for me.

To each their own. (Hey Wish, can we get a Peace Sign emoji?)

 Originally Posted By: Gretsch 6120
Personally, at this point I wouldn’t even bother…..thing is companies like Squire and Epiphone have the best value instruments already dialed in, and I’d much rather have a genuine Squire than a counterfeit Ric or anything else…..

I was typing my long response and didn't see this, but I alluded to it and agree 100%.


gonzo
(Loquacious Planeteer)
02/11/19 07:15 PM
Re: The Top Guitars: WTF?